Carbon fibre, aluminium or titanium: which material for which use?

Coque iPhone en fibre de carbone tissée Fibernium, finition FIBRE, vue de dos

Carbon fibre vs aluminium vs titanium: none of the three wins everywhere. For the same volume, carbon composite is the lightest, with a density close to 1.6 g/cm³, and it excels when a part is loaded along its fibres. Aluminium conducts heat far better, while titanium resists corrosion and keeps a high yield strength. The right choice therefore depends on the load, the heat to dissipate and the weight to save, not on an overall ranking.

This comparison also puts things in perspective: a woven carbon fibre case covers the back of your phone, but it does not replace its frame.

In brief

  • Density: about 1.6 g/cm³ for a carbon composite, 2.8 for aluminium, 4.4 for grade 5 titanium.
  • Stiffness: a carbon fabric nearly matches aluminium at a much lower weight, but carbon depends on the orientation of its fibres, unlike metals.
  • Uses: carbon to lighten a part with known loads, aluminium to dissipate heat, titanium for corrosive environments.

Carbon fibre vs aluminium vs titanium: what do the figures say?

Here are reference values at room temperature. They give orders of magnitude: every alloy and every composite has its own.

Property Carbon/epoxy (fabric) Carbon/epoxy (unidirectional) Aluminium Grade 5 titanium
Density (g/cm³) 1.6 1.6 2.8 4.4
Stiffness, Young's modulus (GPa) 70 135 along the fibres, 10 across 73 115
Strength (MPa) 600 (tensile failure) 1,500 (tensile failure) 275 (yield strength) 830 (yield strength)
Thermal conductivity (W/m·K) not included not included 217 16.7

Sources: ACP Composites table for the composites (epoxy resin, 50% fibre for the fabric, 60% for the unidirectional), lecture by C. Garion, CERN for the metals.

Be careful with the "strength" row: it does not compare the same thing. For metals, it is the threshold beyond which deformation becomes permanent. For composites, it is the failure stress. These figures show a trend, not a winner. We have not included a conductivity for carbon: it varies with the fibre, the resin and the orientation, and our sources give no comparable value.

Why is carbon fibre both light and stiff?

The table shows it if you divide stiffness by density, which engineers call specific stiffness. Our calculation from these values gives about 44 for carbon fabric, 84 for unidirectional along the fibres, and 26 for both aluminium and titanium. In other words, for equal stiffness along the working axis, a carbon part needs less mass.

The downside comes down to two figures: 135 GPa along the fibres, 10 GPa across them. A unidirectional composite is very stiff in one direction and much more flexible in the other. A metal, on the other hand, behaves the same way in all directions. That is why carbon plies are often stacked with alternating orientations, a step described in our feature on how carbon fibre is made.

These values apply to woven or unidirectional composites. In forged carbon, the fibres are laid out at random, so these figures should not be applied to it as they stand. The differences are explained in our article forged carbon or woven carbon fibre.

When is aluminium the best choice?

When heat has to be dissipated. At 217 W/m·K against 16.7 for grade 5 titanium, the aluminium in the table conducts heat about 13 times better. That is a considerable gap for an object packed with electronics.

Smartphones are a good example. Apple describes the iPhone 17 Pro body as an aluminium unibody in a 7000-series alloy, light, strong and thermally conductive, paired with a vapour chamber to dissipate heat better. Two generations earlier, the iPhone 15 Pro had a titanium frame, as we point out in our guide to the iPhone 15 range. So the material follows the priorities of the moment, with no permanent hierarchy.

When is titanium the right call?

Titanium is heavier than aluminium: about 1.6 times according to the table. It earns its place when that weight buys something else. The Royal Society of Chemistry cites two major strengths: its alloys are used in aircraft and spacecraft for their low density and their ability to withstand extreme temperatures, and its corrosion resistance makes it a choice for power plant condensers and for contact with seawater.

Its yield strength matters too: 830 MPa for the grade 5 in the table, against 275 MPa for the reference aluminium. Here again, the comparison depends on the alloy. The same year, Apple chose a grade 5 titanium frame for the iPhone Air and says it exceeds its bend-resistance requirements. On a very thin phone, that is the quality the brand highlights.

Which material should you choose for which use?

Your priority Material to look at first Point to watch
Saving weight on a part with known loads Carbon fibre Orient the fibres according to the loads
Dissipating heat Aluminium Properties vary widely with the alloy
Resisting seawater or corrosion Titanium Much higher mass
Withstanding high temperatures Titanium For carbon, the resin sets the service limit

That last row matters: in a composite, it is not just the fibre doing the work, but also the resin holding it in place. A material data sheet is therefore not enough: you have to look at the finished part.

What do these differences change on a smartphone or an accessory?

You need to distinguish the frame from the case. The frame carries the structure of the device and helps manage heat: that is where the figures above matter most. A case plays a different role: it covers the phone, and choosing one comes down mainly to the visible material, the feel and useful features such as MagSafe.

The properties of a raw material say nothing about how a case behaves in a drop. We untangle this topic in our article on the protection offered by carbon cases.

At Fibernium, FIBRE is a genuine woven carbon plate; FORGE and BRUTE are made of forged carbon; MAILLE combines a carbon and aramid weave. GIVRE and HYBRIDE, from the "Style carbone" range, are made of fibreglass: this comparison does not apply to them.

The Fibernium tip: be wary of claims that reduce a material to a single figure. "Stronger than steel" means nothing unless you specify along which axis, with which resin and compared with which measurement. Ask instead what the part is made of and how it is meant to work.

To see these materials up close:

Frequently asked questions

Is carbon fibre stronger than aluminium?

Along the fibres, a composite reaches high values: 1,500 MPa at failure for the unidirectional in the table. But the result depends on the orientation, the resin and the measurement used. There is no single answer, especially off-axis.

Is titanium lighter than aluminium?

No. According to the values cited, grade 5 titanium has a density of 4.4 against 2.8 for aluminium. Its appeal lies in its yield strength and corrosion resistance, not in absolute lightness.

Does forged carbon have the same properties as woven carbon?

No, and the figures in this article do not apply to it directly. Its fibres are laid out at random, whereas the table describes fabrics and unidirectional layers.

Why does Apple change materials from one generation to the next?

Apple does not explain all its trade-offs. Its press releases highlight the thermal conductivity of aluminium on the iPhone 17 Pro and the bend resistance of titanium on the iPhone Air: each model has its own priorities.

Read also